Security checks / Check reference / Tenant-wide

Auth Policy Guest Same As Member

Medium Severity Microsoft 365 security check in the Tenant-wide domain.

Guest users have the same access as member users. Guests should have restricted default permissions Same-as-member guest access grants external identities full directory read and group enumeration; lateral movement and data discovery become trivial Siemserva runs this check automatically across your tenant and maps every finding to the compliance frameworks below.

Medium SeverityTenant-wide

Check summary

Severity
Medium
Domain
Tenant-wide
Rank in domain
3
Frameworks
5

What this check verifies

Guest users have the same access as member users. Guests should have restricted default permissions

Why it matters

Same-as-member guest access grants external identities full directory read and group enumeration; lateral movement and data discovery become trivial

How to fix it

Set guest access to restricted in authorization policy; limit directory browsing

Siemserva flags every tenant where this check fails and, with Senserva Trustworthy AI remediation, can propose a validated fix you approve before it applies.

Ask your own AI about this check

Copy this prompt into Claude, ChatGPT, or Copilot. The facts are included, sourced from this page.

Compliance framework mappings

Findings from this check serve as evidence for:

SCuBAMCSBNISTSOC2CISMCSB IM-1MCSB PA-1MCSB PA-7

Common questions

What does the Auth Policy Guest Same As Member check verify?

Guest users have the same access as member users. Guests should have restricted default permissions It is a Medium Severity check in the Tenant-wide domain, one of the 650+ checks Siemserva runs across Microsoft 365, Intune, Defender, and Entra ID.

How do I fix a Auth Policy Guest Same As Member finding?

Set guest access to restricted in authorization policy; limit directory browsing Siemserva ranks the finding by Severity and, with Senserva Trustworthy AI, can propose a validated, approve-before-apply configuration fix.

Which compliance frameworks does this check evidence?

Findings from this check map to SCuBA, MCSB, NIST, SOC2, CIS, and MCSB controls IM-1, PA-1, PA-7. That mapping is what turns a scan finding into audit evidence.

Can I ask my own AI about this check?

Yes. This page includes a free copy-paste AI prompt carrying the check's facts: what it verifies, the risk, the remediation, and the framework mappings. Paste it into Claude, ChatGPT, or Copilot; cite-worthy detail without giving an AI access to your tenant.

All 672 checks with severities and mappings: the Microsoft 365 security checks catalog.

Sponsored by Senserva

Siemserva by Senserva runs this check, Auth Policy Guest Same As Member for example, across your own tenant: which tenants pass, which fail, ranked by Severity with the evidence attached.

  • 650+ Microsoft 365, Intune, Defender, and Entra ID checks in one scan
  • Findings mapped to SCuBA, CIS, NIST, HIPAA, SOC 2, and MCSB for audit-ready evidence
  • Senserva Trustworthy AI driven configuration remediation: validated, approve-before-apply fixes
  • Optional AI Enhanced Reporting: plain-language summaries and recommended next steps written into your reports
  • Multi-tenant and MSP practices, with bulk tenant audits and client-ready reporting
Compliance Status Report
Auth Policy Guest Same As Member across 2 tenants, ranked by Severity
23
FAILING
87
PASSING
41
OTHER FINDINGS
CHECKSEVERITYSTATUSFINDINGS
Auth Policy Guest Same As MemberMediumFAILING23
MFA for all usersCritical-11
Legacy authentication blockedHigh-6
Estimated report, sample data for illustration
Get Going with Senserva Senserva compliance Built for IT admins, security teams, and auditors, with audit-ready evidence. Senserva is a Microsoft Intelligent Security Association member.
Microsoft 365 compliance and audit evidence
See this check's evidence trail, click to play

How findings become audit evidence, in two minutes. Watch page · All videos.

Reference: the compliance and audit guide, and the full checks catalog.
Data notice: check definitions describe what Siemserva verifies and are provided as is, for informational purposes only, without warranty of any kind. Framework mappings are informational and do not constitute compliance advice; confirm requirements with your assessor. All use of this data is subject to the Senserva EULA.